This piece is part of OnPoint Perspectives, a thought leadership series inspired by the conversations that shaped Kobie’s annual loyalty conference, OnPoint. Each perspective expands on an idea presented during the event, exploring what it means for loyalty leaders and the decisions they’re making today.
This perspective explores insights shared by Aidan Lundy, Vice President, Managing Director, during OnPoint 2026. Aidan challenged loyalty leaders to reconsider the value already sitting within their programs, particularly the overlooked potential of redemption to create better member experiences and new commercial opportunities.
The Loyalty Opportunity Hiding in Plain Sight
Loyalty programs have spent decades building something extraordinarily valuable: direct relationships with customers who willingly share information.
That understanding powers personalization, rewards, and more relevant experiences, but as commerce media networks create new ways for brands to connect with consumers, it’s worth asking whether loyalty programs are realizing the full value of the relationships they’ve built.
Consider what happens when a member decides to redeem their points.
They’ve moved beyond browsing or casually expressing interest. They’re actively considering how to use value they’ve earned through an ongoing relationship with a brand.
For the member, it’s an opportunity to enjoy the benefits of loyalty. For the program operator, it’s traditionally been viewed through a different lens: the cost of fulfilling a reward.
What if that same moment could create value for both?
That’s the opportunity behind commerce loyalty, and it begins by rethinking what redemption actually represents.
Redemption Is More Than a Cost of Doing Business
Loyalty economics have long treated outstanding points as a liability and redemption as the moment that liability becomes an expense.
It’s a necessary part of operating a program, but that financial perspective can obscure what redemption tells us about the customer.
A member who redeems is actively participating in the relationship. They’ve earned something valuable, found a reason to use it, and experienced the return on their engagement.
That matters.
Redemption can reinforce the value of membership, encourage continued participation, and strengthen the connection between the customer and the brand.
It also provides insight into what the member values.
Someone redeeming points toward a family vacation is expressing a different set of priorities than someone choosing cash back or merchandise. Those choices can help brands understand what motivates members and where additional value might be meaningful.
Rather than viewing redemption exclusively as an expense to manage, loyalty leaders have an opportunity to see it as a moment of demonstrated intent and an opening to deepen the relationship.
The Value of Knowing When Someone Is Ready to Choose
Brands invest heavily in understanding what consumers might want.
They analyze behavior, build audiences, and use predictive models to identify people who may be interested in particular products or experiences.
Loyalty programs have an advantage in this environment: an established customer relationship that provides context for those signals.
A member’s history, preferences, and engagement can help explain what they value. Their redemption activity adds another dimension by revealing when they’re considering an exchange of value.
Think about a member preparing to redeem points for an upcoming trip.
The brand may already understand that member’s travel preferences, past experiences, and relationship with the program. That context creates an opportunity to introduce a relevant partner benefit or additional redemption option that complements what the member is trying to accomplish.
The value comes from bringing the right opportunity into a moment when the customer has a genuine reason to consider it.
This is an important distinction from simply placing more promotions in front of members.
The goal is to make an existing decision more valuable.
The Commercial Opportunity Should Strengthen the Member Experience
Commerce media has demonstrated that brands are willing to invest in reaching relevant audiences.
Loyalty introduces an important consideration: the audience isn’t simply a collection of potential buyers. It’s a community of members who have an existing relationship with a brand and expectations about the value that relationship provides.
Any new commercial opportunity needs to respect that foundation.
Partners can introduce additional choices, access to products or experiences, and benefits that a loyalty program may not offer independently.
Done thoughtfully, those opportunities can make redemption more useful and compelling for members while creating another source of economic value for the program.
The key is selectivity.
A partner opportunity should make sense for the member, align with the program’s promise, and offer something meaningfully relevant to the decision at hand.
More choice isn’t automatically better. A crowded redemption experience filled with loosely related offers could undermine the very relationship that makes loyalty valuable.
The opportunity is to create a more intentional exchange, one in which members see additional value, partners reach relevant customers, and program operators have a reason to invest further in the experience.
That is a different proposition from turning a loyalty program into another advertising channel.
A Different Way to Think About Loyalty Economics
For many program operators, the pressure to deliver more value while managing costs is only increasing.
Redemption costs, outstanding liabilities, and expectations for measurable returns all influence how loyalty investments are evaluated.
Commerce loyalty introduces the possibility of improving that equation without asking members to accept less.
When a relevant partner participates in a redemption experience, the commercial value of that participation could help offset program costs or support additional investment in member benefits.
The broader implication is important: program economics and customer experience don’t have to be competing priorities.
A more valuable redemption experience can encourage members to engage with the program, while a more sustainable economic model can give brands greater flexibility to improve what they offer.
Of course, realizing that opportunity requires careful consideration. Not every program has the same member base, redemption behaviors, partner ecosystem, or commercial objectives.
The right approach starts with understanding where members already exchange value and identifying opportunities that would genuinely improve those experiences.
It also requires discipline about how partner participation is introduced, ensuring that short-term commercial returns don’t come at the expense of long-term trust. necessarily be those that launch the most ambitious AI experiences first. They’ll be those that have built a strong foundation of customer understanding, demonstrable value, and trust.
Loyalty’s Next Opportunity May Be to Recognize Its Own Value
The emergence of commerce loyalty networks reflects a broader shift in how brands think about customer relationships.
For years, loyalty has helped organizations collect valuable data, understand customer behavior, and build ongoing engagement.
Now, there is an opportunity to reconsider how those existing assets can create value in new ways.
The underlying relationships are already there. So are the member preferences, engagement signals, and moments when customers actively choose how to use their benefits.
What’s changing is the ability to connect those assets to broader commerce opportunities more intentionally.
For loyalty leaders, the question isn’t simply how to monetize another customer touchpoint. It’s how to make the value exchange already happening inside the program more useful for members and more sustainable for the business.
That is what makes commerce loyalty worth paying attention to.
Sometimes the next opportunity for growth isn’t about building something entirely new. It’s about recognizing the full potential of what you’ve already built.
From the OnPoint 2026 Agenda
Commerce Loyalty: The Business Model Hidden in Plain Sight
Aidan Lundy, Vice President, Managing Director
Session overview:
Commerce media networks are evolving how value is created and exchanged, and loyalty programs sit closer to this shift than many brands realize. Commerce already exists inside loyalty, particularly in moments like redemption, where customers are actively choosing how to exchange value.
This session explored how those moments can be structured more intentionally to deliver relevance, create new sources of value, and introduce optionality through partners without turning loyalty into advertising.
The session included:
- A clearer view of how value exchange already exists within your loyalty program
- Criteria for evaluating partner, redemption, and optionality opportunities
- Strategic considerations for aligning loyalty with emerging commerce ecosystems
To learn more about this proprietary thought leadership or Kobie’s annual OnPoint conference, reach out to the Kobie team.









