This piece is part of OnPoint Perspectives, a thought leadership series inspired by the conversations that shaped Kobie’s annual loyalty conference, OnPoint. Each perspective expands on an idea presented during the event, exploring what it means for loyalty leaders and the decisions they’re making today.
This perspective explores insights shared by Dr. JR Slubowski, Vice President of Strategic Consulting, during the opening session at OnPoint 2026. During the live session, JR unpacked these ideas through proprietary research, behavioral science, and practical frameworks designed to help loyalty leaders apply the findings within their own organizations.
Loyalty Leaders Have Better Data Than Ever.
So Why Are We Still Asking the Wrong Questions?
Loyalty has never had more data, more technology, or more opportunity. Yet many brands are still struggling to create the kinds of experiences customers actually want.
The problem may not be a lack of information. It may be the assumptions behind the questions we’re asking.
For years, loyalty leaders have focused on familiar challenges:
- How do we convince customers to share more data?
- Are consumers ready for AI?
- How do we generate more referrals?
These are reasonable questions, but they reflect a view of customer behavior that is changing quickly.
That shift became clear in this year’s edition of Kobie’s Heart of Loyalty Study, which surveyed 8,000 consumers across 6 countries alongside 338 loyalty practitioners. The research highlighted something significant: customers and brands are no longer always operating from the same set of assumptions.
Understanding those gaps may be one of the biggest competitive advantages loyalty leaders have today.
The conversation around data sharing is shifting
Conversations around zero-party data often begin with trust. Brands invest in privacy policies, consent language, and data governance, assuming these are the primary barriers to sharing personal information.
Those investments matter. Customers expect brands to protect their data and communicate clearly about how it will be used, but our research found that the strongest drivers of data sharing are often much more tangible.
Customers want to know what they receive in return. They respond to relevant experiences, meaningful rewards, and visible outcomes that make sharing their information feel worthwhile. They also prefer to share information gradually through simple, low-effort interactions rather than lengthy forms or profile centers.
Trust remains essential, but value is what motivates participation. For loyalty leaders, that shifts the conversation from collecting more data to creating more meaningful exchanges.
Consumers may be moving faster than organizations on AI
Few topics generate as much discussion today as artificial intelligence. Most organizations are carefully evaluating where AI belongs within the customer experience.
Consumers, however, may already be further along than many brands realize.
Our research found that willingness to adopt AI has less to do with age or technical sophistication than many expect. Instead, adoption is driven by whether AI feels useful, easy to engage with, and personally motivating. Customers are comfortable interacting with AI when it helps them accomplish something more efficiently or creates a better experience.
Meanwhile, many loyalty organizations continue to focus their AI investments behind the scenes, using it primarily for internal productivity, content generation, or operational efficiencies.
Those use cases create value for the business, but they don’t necessarily move the customer experience forward.
The opportunity is to thoughtfully introduce AI into the loyalty experience in ways that customers find genuinely valuable.
Advocacy is more than another acquisition strategy
Referral programs have long been part of loyalty, but referral and advocacy are often treated as interchangeable concepts.
They’re different.
A referral is an action. Advocacy is an identity.
People advocate for brands that reflect who they are and what they value. That emotional connection changes both the intensity and authenticity of their behavior. They recommend brands because they genuinely want others to experience them, not simply because an incentive exists.
That distinction matters because it changes how brands should think about growth.
The strongest advocates aren’t created through referral mechanics alone. They’re developed through experiences that consistently reinforce trust, recognition, and shared values over time.
The biggest shift is in our perspective
Perhaps the most important takeaway from this year’s research isn’t any individual statistic.
It’s the realization that many of the questions loyalty leaders have been asking were shaped by yesterday’s customer.
Today’s consumers are:
- Comfortable sharing data when the value is clear.
- Open to AI when it improves their lives.
- Building deeper relationships with brands that reflect their identity and values.
- Looking for experiences that feel relevant, timely, and personal.
The brands that succeed will update the assumptions guiding every loyalty decision they make.
That’s ultimately what the Heart of Loyalty Study is designed to do.
Not provide all the answers.
Help loyalty leaders ask better questions.
From the OnPoint 2026 Agenda
Kobie’s Heart of Loyalty Study
Dr. JR Slubowski, Vice President of Strategic Consulting
Session overview
Consumer perceptions are shifting in ways that are subtle yet consequential. Drawing on global proprietary research from our annual Heart of Loyalty Study, this session explored consumer and loyalty practitioner perspectives on values-aligned emotional loyalty, advocacy, referral, community-based engagement, AI readiness, and the factors that influence consumers’ willingness to share personal information. By combining original research with behavioral science, the session challenged long-held assumptions and highlighted the opportunities and risks shaping the future of loyalty.
The session included:
- Insights into what earns customers’ trust when sharing data, and what undermines it.
- A clearer understanding of what drives emotional loyalty, advocacy, and referral.
- A practical lens for evaluating whether today’s loyalty strategies reflect how customers are actually thinking and making decisions.

To learn more about this proprietary thought leadership or Kobie’s annual OnPoint conference, reach out to the Kobie team.









