This piece is part of our 2026 holiday strategy thought leadership series. For the full picture, read the 2026 Holiday Playbook, and contact the Kobie team to see how we can help your brand turn holiday activity into lessons that carry into next year.
The holidays have always been one of retail’s most important selling seasons. It is when traffic rises, promotional intensity spikes and consumers are pushed to make more purchase decisions in a shorter period of time.
For loyalty teams, holiday should be viewed as something more than a revenue event. It is also one of the richest learning windows of the year.
During the season, customers shop more often, explore unfamiliar categories, move across more channels and sometimes buy for people other than themselves. New shoppers enter the brand through promotions. Dormant members resurface. Loyal customers behave outside their normal patterns. Plus, transactions increasingly happen in places where the loyalty relationship is harder to see.
All of that creates signals.
The opportunity is to use the season not just to ask, “How much did we sell?” but also, “What did we learn about the customer relationship?”
Holiday behavior gives you more to learn from
Holiday compresses months of shopper behavior into a much more active period.
Customers may visit more frequently, spend across new categories, use rewards differently or engage with channels they rarely use during the rest of the year. That can make historical behavior less predictive in the moment, but it also gives loyalty teams new context.
Kobie’s 2026 retail research shows just how dynamic those relationships can be. Nearly 45% of retail loyalty members say they at least sometimes discover products through social channels, while almost 35% use AI tools to research products. At the same time, loyalty attribution becomes much weaker once the shopper leaves a brand-owned environment. While 66% of consumers attribute their loyalty to the brand when shopping on the brand’s own site or app, that drops to 33% on third-party marketplaces and 29% in social commerce.
Holiday intensifies those behaviors.
That means the sale itself may only tell you part of the story. The bigger question is what happened around it.
Look for what holds steady
One of the most valuable holiday signals is consistency.
Which members continue to engage even when competitors are running aggressive promotions? Which benefits are still being used when the market is saturated with discounts? Which shoppers continue to choose the brand when they have more alternatives than usual?
These are the relationships worth studying closely. Holiday provides an opportunity to see which relationships hold up under pressure.
That insight can help brands understand what is driving loyalty beyond the promotion itself, whether that is recognition, convenience, access, habit or simply the confidence that the program will deliver what it promised.
Look for what changes
Holiday is equally useful for spotting behavior that breaks from the norm.
A long-time member suddenly buying in a new category might be developing a new interest. Or they might be shopping for a gift.
A dormant customer returning in December might be re-engaging with the brand. Or they might simply have a one-time seasonal need.
A guest purchase may belong to a completely new customer. Or it may come from an existing member whose loyalty identity was never attached to the transaction.
Those distinctions matter.
The goal should not be to treat every holiday action as a permanent new truth about the customer. Instead, holiday behavior should add context to the profile you already have.
That is especially important when shoppers are buying for others. A single gifting purchase should not automatically rewrite years of known preference data.
Sometimes the best response is to ask.
Consumers are generally receptive to sharing when the exchange is simple and useful. In Kobie’s 2026 Heart of Loyalty research, 71% of consumers said they were willing to share information through a one-time mini-survey and 64% through a short-form quiz. 81% said they would not share if they felt they were being asked for too much at once.
Holiday can be an ideal time to use those lightweight signals to better understand intent.
Look for what sticks
Some of the most important holiday learnings do not show up until January.
Which Holiday Newcomers came back? Which dormant members stayed active? Which category shifts disappeared once gifting ended? Which shoppers continued using the program after the promotional intensity faded?
Those are the signals that help distinguish seasonal activity from something more durable.
This is particularly important because promotional acquisition does not automatically translate into loyalty. Kobie’s Retail Deep Dive Study found that 78% of retail loyalty members join programs primarily for deals and promotions. After a sales event, 58% say they are likely to look for similar products elsewhere at a lower price, and 47% say they may shift some spending to a competitor running another promotion.
The holiday sale may have brought someone in. What happens next tells you where the relationship stands.
Use holiday as a learning loop
The best use of holiday data is not simply to build a better holiday plan next year. The season can inform decisions across the loyalty strategy.
What you learn can help refine segmentation, personalization, recognition, journey design, channel strategy and post-promotion engagement. It can reveal where customer identity falls out of the journey, where offers create short-term activity but little relationship value, and where the loyalty experience genuinely strengthens the bond.
It can also help loyalty teams stay more flexible while the season is still underway.
If response begins to fall, a particular channel underperforms or Holiday Newcomers fail to take a second action, those signals can help teams decide whether to adjust or hold steady. The objective is not to react to every fluctuation. It is to know which changes deserve attention.
The opportunity
Holiday will always be a selling season. It is also one of the clearest opportunities retailers have to watch customers make choices under pressure, across more occasions and more channels than usual.
Use the season to understand what remains true, what changes temporarily and what may signal a deeper shift in the relationship.
Because the brands that get the most value from holiday will not just ask:
How did we perform?
They will also ask:
What did this season teach us about our customers, and what should we do differently because of it?
Reach us at https://kobie.com/contact/ to learn more.









